Ranking the Plaques in Yankee Stadium's Monument Park - Part II

By

Last month we began our review and rankings of the plaques on display at Monument Park. We're back with a new batch of bronze. The eight plaques featured here are a notch above the group we looked at last time, but they're not anything to write home about either. Rest assured that things will be looking pretty good from here on out.

Ground-level view of the original Monument Park in Old Yankee Stadium.
wallyg/Wikimedia Commons

As was the case last time, I won't share a picture of every plaque because they tend to run together and get redundant as you scan through them. For any that I don't have a picture of below, it's relatively easy to find via google.

24. Lou Gehrig - dedicated on July 4, 1941

A minimilast approach here for Lou, whose plaque was the second one commissioned by the Yankees after Miller Huggins. The first bit reads just like Babe Ruth's plaque, and awkwardly starts with this sentence: "A man." His consecutive games streak is mentioned, as it should be, but I must deduct points for no mention of his "Luckiest man" speech and the fact that they infuriatingly separated the word "teammate" into two words in the last sentence.

23. Joe McCarthy - dedicated on April 21, 1976

For such a great manager, Joe McCarthy's plaque is underwhelming.
Penale52/Wikimedia Commons

Another short, but sweet one. It has a promising start, as we learn that McCarthy was a beloved and respected leader. Unfortunately, we have no idea why because the plaque then trails off into an underwhelming list of accomplishments. You would expect a little more for arguably the most successful manager in franchise history.

22. Joe DiMaggio - dedicated on April 25, 1999

On the surface, DiMaggio's plaque - which became a monument after his death in 1999 - is a dud. The meat of it is simply a list of statistics and awards. However, the things they fit around the edges really improve the final product. We see his nickname (The Yankee Clipper), we learn about his crowning acheivement (the 56-game hitting streak), and we understand that he was considered the "greatest living ballplayer" for a long time. You can read this one and at least start to understand what made DiMaggio a mythical figure.

21. Thurman Munson - dedicated on September 20, 1980

This is a plaque unlike any other in Monument Park. It's simply a quote, seemingly from his teammates, that reflects their love and admiration for their captain. It doen't suffer the same fate of many modern plaques (listing a bunch of stats), which is refreshing. This was dedicated only a year after his untimely death, so you can forgive the Yankees for not really capturing the full context of his career, but it feels like more could be said about the iconic backstop.

20. Ron Guidry - dedicated on August 23, 2003

Guidry's long overdue dedication contains the usual nonsense we've seen in the rankings thus far, and therefore it uses too many words. Yet there are some redeeming qualities here. The plaque describes him as a respected leader and dominating pitcher, so we start to get a glimpse at the kind of character that Guidry was. We also get the bonus of both of his nicknames - Gator and Louisiana Lightning - included right at the top. You don't have to stretch your mind too much to read this and pitcture why it was so much fun to watch Guidry pitch in the late 70's.

19. Tino Martinez - dedicated on June 21, 2014

To put Tino's plaque in baseball terms, it's "replacement level".

There was nothing super exciting about Tino as a player - had had no major strengths or glaring weaknesses - and his plaque reflects that. It's a perfectly adequate script that tells us why Tino was important without relying heavily on stats. The most interesting thing here is that it looks nothing at all like Tino Martinez. He looks more like Wellington Mara with a Yankee hat on.

18. Don Mattingly - dedicated on August 31, 1997

My admiration for Don Mattingly is well-documented, so I have to swallow hard when I see that the bulk of his plaque is literally a list of accomplishments. Thankfully, they included "Donnie Baseball" at the top and four succinct sentences at the bottom that perfectly describe why Mattingly was a hero whom millions of Yankee fans still look up to.

17. Willie Randolph - dedicated on June 20, 2015

If Guidry's plaque was overdue, then the amount of time the Yankees made Randolph wait for his was criminal. It reads as basically the inverse of Mattingly's - his partner for many years on the right side of the Yankee infield. The first paragraph gives us a great summary of Willie's unique abilities as both a hitter and fielder. The rest is the usual nonsense with the only saving grace being that they acknowledge his success as a third base coach. If they had stopped after the first two sentences here, it might be in the top half of the rankings.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Buddy, 20?? - 2024

By
Image
In the neighborhood I grew up in there was a dog named Shannon. To this day I'd probably count her as the nicest dog I've ever met. She was a Sheltie who was eager to make friends with everybody she encountered - including kids - and had boundless energy for play, especially if a tennis ball was involved. She was a joy to be around. When I was seven years old what I wanted more than anything in the world was a dog of my own. As luck would have it, Shannon was due to have a litter of puppies around that time and my parents agreed that we could adopt one. In the summer of 1990 we had a new family member named Mickey. He was an interesting looking mutt with the body frame and hair texture of his mother combined with floppy ears and the hair color of a Rottweiler. More importantly, he inherited Shannon's friendless and desire for playtime, albeit with the protective streak of a shepherd as he barked at any living thing that dared come near the house. Life with Mickey was everyt...
Read more

Jimmy Sez Meets More All-Stars

By
Image
Last year I told the story of meeting Don Mattingly and from there committed to the quest of getting the rest of the living Yankees All-Time All-Stars to sign a copy of the book. Luckily, the folks at Hall of Fame Signings hosted another Pinstripe Pride event earlier this month in north Jersey. There, I was able to get the autographs of five more legends, which means seven of the 17 living All-Stars have now signed. While it was thrilling to meet each of the five who signed this year, I won't have nearly as much to say about the encounter as I did with Donnie Baseball. Ya know, you only get to meet your childhood hero for the first time once. So here's a brief description of each exchange with a picture of my ugly mug next to some guys that you'd much rather see. Before digging in, I do need to give a shout out to Hall of Fame Signings for a dramatically improved experience at the event for 2024. There was far more space at the venue, organization, and predictability wh...
Read more

Yankees on the 2021 BBWAA HoF Ballot - AV (Aging Veterans) Club

By
Image
A few weeks ago we covered the former Yankees on the 2021 Hall of Fame ballot who earned a championship ring in pinstripes. Here we'll take a look at four players who joined the Yankees when they were well into their 30's and past their prime. For each player, their JAWS (Jaffe Average WAR Score, developed by Jay Jaffe) value is given along with the average Hall of Famer's JAWS at they player's position. JAWS is a Hall of Fame rating system based on WAR that incorporates both career and peak value. If you're interested in learning more about this, click here . Gary Sheffield - Right Field, JAWS: 49.3, HoF JAWS: 57.2 A Gary Sheffield at bat was a sight to behold. Most of the great swings throughout baseball history could be described as beautiful, elegant or graceful, but a Sheffield swing would best be described as an act of violence. Before each pitch he would tilt his bat from an upright position back and forth towards the pitcher, like a pendulum getting increas...
Read more