Yankees on the 2027 Contemporary Baseball Era HoF Ballot
I stayed away from writing about the Yankees all summer for two main reasons: (1) The Knicks were way more fun to write about, (2) There's nothing new to say about the Yankees. They made the playoffs, fell short of a World Series title, and ownership will do nothing about it. Same story for many years now. But I'm back with some Yankees-related content because it's the most wonderful time of the year, Hall of Fame season!
The folks in Cooperstown just announced this year's Veterans Committee ballot which includes managers, executives, and umpires from the Contemporary Baseball Era (1980-present). There are three guys on the ballot who were involved with the Yankees' organization at one point or another throughout their career. Two of them have a serious shot at election, but the members that make up these committees can be fickle sorts, making the elections tough to predict. I'll be pulling for them anyway.
Brian Sabean
Sabean is the rare baseball lifer who spent almost none of it actually playing baseball. After playing college ball at a small Division-II school in Florida, he started his non-playing journey as a 22-year old manager of a team in the now famous Cape Cod Baseball League. He spent the next eight years serving in various coaching roles at colleges in Florida before getting his first major league job in 1985, as a scout for the Yankees. He worked his way up the Tampa-based brain trust and by 1990 was the vice president of player development scouting for the organization. Under his watch the Yankees drafted Jorge Posada, Andy Pettitte, and Derek Jeter and signed Mariano Rivera as an amateur free agent. Not exactly lightweights.
Sabean didn't directly experience the fruits of his labor in New York as he took an assistant general manager position with the San Francisco Giants in 1993. By 1996 he was promoted to general manager of the struggling franchise and thanks to a few shrewd trades quickly brought them back to respectability in the late 90's. The Giants nearly ended a 48-year World Series drought in 2002, but fell short in seven games to a red hot Angels team and began a steady decline thereafter.
By the end of the 2000's, Sabean realized that relying on aging veterans wasn't working so he re-built through the draft with players like Buster Posey and Madison Bumgarner and supplemented the roster by acquiring players still in their prime. The results were monumental. Over the five seasons from 2010 through 2014 the Giants won the World Series three times, cementing his legacy as one of baseball's great architects. In 2015 Sabean abdicated his GM responsibilities and climbed the corporate ladder with the Giants. They haven't returned to the World Series since. Prior to the 2023 season, Brian Cashman brought Sabean back to the Yankees as an executive advisor, where he also failed to add another World Series to his résumé over four seasons. He's an executive free agent heading into the 2027 season.
Baseball figures who build and oversee a team that wins three World Series titles over a short time period are typically recognized as Hall of Famers. However, this will be a particularly difficult ballot for Sabean to break through due to the presence of Bruce Bochy and Dusty Baker. Baker was the Giants' manager during Sabean's first World Series appearance in 2002 and had subsequent success with multiple franchises, including a World Series win in 2022 with the Astros. Bochy was Sabean's manager for all three World Series wins and later won a World Series with the Texas Rangers. The faces of Sabean's most successful teams will likely outshine him on this ballot. Making matters more difficult, the way the math works out on these ballots (16 voters get a maximum of three votes each, 12 votes needed for the candidate to be elected) means that there is rarely more than one candidate that gets voted in each cycle. Sabean will get his Hall of Fame plaque some day, I just don't think it will be this year.
Bill White
I've written before about how much I loved hearing Phil Rizzuto call Yankee games. This isn't exactly a hot take. Generations of Yankee fans grew up to the sound of the Scooter serving as the soundtrack for the Yankees and love him just as much as I do. During Phil's golden years of broadcasting, Bill White was right there with him as his straight man. From 1971 to 1988 White called Yankee games on both TV and radio, developing a chemistry with Rizzuto that was as close to perfection as a baseball broadcasting pair can get. (Nb: Vin Scully's solo act was actual perfection.)
Considering his lack of any connection to the Yankees prior to joining their broadcast booth, White's long, successful run there stands as a testament to his quality as an announcer. His wealth of baseball knowledge stood for itself, but he also had the ability to take Rizzuto's tangents in stride and keep the action moving without getting in the way. Even more impressive, he did this as the first black announcer to broadcast games regularly for a major league sports team, and in the hotbed of New York City nonetheless. But then again, breaking new ground was something of a trademark for Bill White.
In 1953, White became just the second black minor leaguer to play in the Carolina League, which served as a springboard to a very successful major league career. In 13 seasons - mostly spent with the St. Louis Cardinals - he was a slick-fielding, powerful first baseman who could also hit for average. He was named an All-Star in five different seasons, earned seven Gold Gloves and served as a key player on the 1964 World Series champions. He spent the last few years of his playing career with the Phillies and began his broadcasting career in Philadelphia when his playing days were over. There, he became the first black broadcaster to call an NHL game when the Flyers enlisted his services.
During White's run with the Yankees he took part in ABC's broadcast coverage of the Winter Olympics in 1980 and 1984. Showing even further versatility and respect among his peers, White was voted in as president of the National League in 1989 after he retired from broadcasting. Of course, that meant he was the first black person to serve as the president of a major league. He held the position until 1994.
White was last on a Hall of Fame ballot for the 2024 Contemporary Era Committee and earned 10 votes, just shy of the 12 needed for election. That would give him a really good shot at election this year, but there's a catch. This past summer, White was the recipient of the Baseball Hall of Fame's Buck O'Neil Lifetime Achievement Award, which is given every three years to someone who "enhances baseball's positive image on society, who broadens the game's appeal, and whose integrity and dignity are comparable to the namesake of the award, John Jordan 'Buck' O'Neil."
If anybody fits that bill, it's Bill White, but what does it mean for his chances for earning entrance to the plaque room in Cooperstown this year? Will voters dismiss him because he already has the Buck O'Neil Award? Will that award put him in better perspective for more voters? If he does gain election, I hope it's this year for the 92-year old White. Too often, Hall of Fame voters elect new members posthumously when it would have been much more meaningful to see them enjoy the honor in person.
Lou Piniella
Sweet Lou spent 15 years of his long baseball career as a Yankee in some way, shape or form. A former Rookie of the Year and All-Star with the Royals, Piniella was traded to the Yankees prior to the 1974 season. For the next 11 years he was a key contributor to the Yankees mainly in a hybrid fourth outfielder/designated hitter role. Despite never being a true star with the Yankees, he was as recognizable as anyone on the Bronx Zoo teams thanks to his steady bat, hard-nosed attitude, and of course, his association with a winning brand of baseball.
It was no surprise, then, that Piniella was hired as the Yankees' hitting coach even before he officially retired as a player in 1984. After some success in that role, he was hired as manager for the 1986 and '87 seasons where he led solid teams that ultimately fell short of the playoffs. In 1988 he was promoted to general manager to make room for Billy Martin to take over as manager (again). He found that a front office position was too far removed from the field and stepped down that May, only to be re-hired as manager (again) when Martin was fired by George Steinbrenner for the fifth and final time. After a disappointing stretch run in '88, Piniella would move on from the Yankees.
Lou would go on to manage for another 20 big league seasons, starting with a three-year stint in Cincinnati. In 1990 he would pilot the Reds to a shocking World Series sweep over the 103-win Oakland A's. That would serve as the apex of his managerial career. He would never reach the World Series again.
That's not to say that the balance of Piniella's career was uneventful. In 1993 he signed on as manager of the upstart Seattle Mariners, featuring one of the games brightest young stars in Ken Griffey, Jr. It took just two years for that team to stun the baseball world by winning the 1995 AL Division Series after going down 2-0 in a best-of-five. It was extra sweet for Lou as he broke the Yankees' hearts in the process. Revenge for the Yankees was even sweeter a few years later when they defeated Piniella's Mariners in both the 2000 and 2001 ALCS. However, Piniella would tie a record by winning 116 games during the regular season in 2001. He gladly would have traded a few of those wins for another trip to the Fall Classic, but it was a significant achievement nonetheless.
As Piniella approached his 60th birthday, the Tampa native began to feel homesick and took a job with the Devil Rays. His hope was to turn around a franchise that had yet to win even 70 games in a season up to that point. He did get them over that hump, winning exactly 70 games in 2004, but that was the extent of his success in Tampa. Unless you also want to count the bizarre scenario where he dyed his hair after a three-game winning streak.
Looking for one last feather in his cap, Piniella was named manager of the Chicago Cubs in 2007. The Cubs took the NL Central crown in each of his first two seasons on the job - including a 97-win campaign in 2008 that saw Piniella win his third Manager of the Year award. Yet they were swept in the first round of the playoffs both times. The club was clearly on the downswing after that and at 66 years old, Sweet Lou retired for good as a manager before the close of the 2010 season.
When you combine his time as a player, coach, manager, general manager, consultant, and broadcaster, Piniella has dedicated nearly 60 years of his life to baseball. Like Bill White, that makes him a prime candidate for the Buck O'Neil Award, but we're a couple years away from the next recipient. Piniella's best and quickest route to Cooperstown will be by getting 12 votes from the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee. This is not his first go at this. He was on veterans committee ballots in 2018 and 2023 and both times earned a tantalizing 11 votes. Whether he earns the extra vote needed this time or is the next man up for the Buck O'Neil Award, I just hope the 83-year Piniella is alive to enjoy the recognition he deserves.



The Yankees names on the Contemporary Era ballot always spark a good debate, and the case for each of them is stronger than people remember. I like to watch wrestling and baseball live online during the season, and Hall of Fame discussions like this are part of what makes baseball so much fun. Good breakdown of the candidates.
ReplyDelete