Ranking the Plaques in Yankee Stadium's Monument Park - Part III

By

In our first two installments of this series we covered the bottom half - in terms of quality - of plaques currently sitting behind the centerfield wall of Yankee Stadium. Now we're ready to dive into the good ones, the ones that start to capture the essence of why these guys matter to the most successful franchise in baseball history. If you ever visit Monument Park with the intention of learning something about the Yankees, I would start with these.

In the bottom left corner above, you can see the original three monuments in the field of play at Old Yankee Stadium.
Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain

As was the case previously, I won't share a picture of every plaque because they tend to run together and get redundant as you scan through them. For any that I don't have a picture of below, it's relatively easy to find via google.

16. Phil Rizzuto - dedicated on August 5, 1985

Scooter's plaque was made in 1985, so I know this isn't the case, but I could swear this one was written by AI software. It gets the job done, but it's quite awkward. What it lacks in style, it makes up for in completeness. You've got a generic quote, a bunch accomplishments listed, a mention of his stellar broadcasting career, and they even snuck in a "Holy Cow". At the very least, it makes you think about Rizzuto's rich Yankee legacy.

15. Mel Stottlemyre - dedicated on June 20, 2015

The long overdue dedication for Stottlemyre runs on a bit due to the usual fluff of stats and accomplishments. But there's some real good stuff in there. It's clear that Mel stood out among his peers and that he was a Yankee lifer who might be the best righthander in franchise history. The additional touches about his hitting ability and highly successful coaching career earns this one a high score.

14. Red Ruffing - dedicated on July 10, 2004

Essentially a more succinct version of Stottlemyre's plaque, which makes sense since they were very simialr pitchers. Both were strong, durable righties that could handle the bat very well. Ruffing's plaque also has a mention of his military career - the only one in Monument Park to do so. However, what stands out most about Red's plaque is the fact that it was dedicated in 2004, nearly 60 years after he pitched his last game as a Yankee. What took them so long to honor the guy?

13. Miller Huggins - dedicated on May 30, 1932

Wikimedia Commons/Silent Wind of Doom

The original, the one that started it all. It's real short and real sweet, getting its point across without too much fluff. You can walk away from this one knowing full well that Huggins orchestrated the first real success of the storied franchise. There's also and odd mention of his "priceless contribution to baseball", which makes me think it's something other than leading the Yankees to the World Series, but I have no idea what it could be.

12. Bernie Williams - dedicated on May 24, 2015

As you can tell by now, I'm no fan of a plaque that leans too heavily on stats and accomplishments. This is the rare exception. When it comes to Bernie Williams, highlighting his numbers helps underscore his standing among all-time greats, even though he was never given that respect when he played. The mentions of his playoff success help further cement his legacy as an all-time Yankee. If you questioned Bernie's worthiness of a plaque before reading it, you'll walk away convinced he's earned it.

11. Paul O'Neill - dedicated on August 9, 2014

Right off the bat this one is a winner. We immediately learn about what kind of player O'Neill, even if it then just rambles off a bunch of numbers that don't mean much without context. There's no doubt here that he was a competitor, a leader, and pursued perfection at all costs. We even get "The Warrior" nickname which paints a vivid picture of O'Neill going all out in the field.

10. Joe Torre - dedicated on August 23, 2014

I'm struck by the unfortunate rendering of poor Joe Torre here. He looks exactly like Peter Boyle in Young Frankenstein, and that's not a compliment. Once you get past the monster face, you'll find one of the best sentences on any plaque in Monument Park. They could have stopped after that first sentence and left it a perfect plaque. As usual, it trails off unnecessarily.

9. Mariano Rivera - dedicated on August 14, 2016

It's too long and there's too many stats, but this one covers all of the important aspects of Mariano Rivera. He's the greatest closer of all time, he was even better in October, his cutter was dominant, he was cool as a cucumber on the mound, and he's well respected by everyone in sports. You can't get more comprehensive than that. I just wish the nickname they chose was "The Sandman" rather than "Mo".

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Buddy, 20?? - 2024

By
Image
In the neighborhood I grew up in there was a dog named Shannon. To this day I'd probably count her as the nicest dog I've ever met. She was a Sheltie who was eager to make friends with everybody she encountered - including kids - and had boundless energy for play, especially if a tennis ball was involved. She was a joy to be around. When I was seven years old what I wanted more than anything in the world was a dog of my own. As luck would have it, Shannon was due to have a litter of puppies around that time and my parents agreed that we could adopt one. In the summer of 1990 we had a new family member named Mickey. He was an interesting looking mutt with the body frame and hair texture of his mother combined with floppy ears and the hair color of a Rottweiler. More importantly, he inherited Shannon's friendless and desire for playtime, albeit with the protective streak of a shepherd as he barked at any living thing that dared come near the house. Life with Mickey was everyt...
Read more

Jimmy Sez Meets More All-Stars

By
Image
Last year I told the story of meeting Don Mattingly and from there committed to the quest of getting the rest of the living Yankees All-Time All-Stars to sign a copy of the book. Luckily, the folks at Hall of Fame Signings hosted another Pinstripe Pride event earlier this month in north Jersey. There, I was able to get the autographs of five more legends, which means seven of the 17 living All-Stars have now signed. While it was thrilling to meet each of the five who signed this year, I won't have nearly as much to say about the encounter as I did with Donnie Baseball. Ya know, you only get to meet your childhood hero for the first time once. So here's a brief description of each exchange with a picture of my ugly mug next to some guys that you'd much rather see. Before digging in, I do need to give a shout out to Hall of Fame Signings for a dramatically improved experience at the event for 2024. There was far more space at the venue, organization, and predictability wh...
Read more

Yankees on the 2021 BBWAA HoF Ballot - AV (Aging Veterans) Club

By
Image
A few weeks ago we covered the former Yankees on the 2021 Hall of Fame ballot who earned a championship ring in pinstripes. Here we'll take a look at four players who joined the Yankees when they were well into their 30's and past their prime. For each player, their JAWS (Jaffe Average WAR Score, developed by Jay Jaffe) value is given along with the average Hall of Famer's JAWS at they player's position. JAWS is a Hall of Fame rating system based on WAR that incorporates both career and peak value. If you're interested in learning more about this, click here . Gary Sheffield - Right Field, JAWS: 49.3, HoF JAWS: 57.2 A Gary Sheffield at bat was a sight to behold. Most of the great swings throughout baseball history could be described as beautiful, elegant or graceful, but a Sheffield swing would best be described as an act of violence. Before each pitch he would tilt his bat from an upright position back and forth towards the pitcher, like a pendulum getting increas...
Read more